CGI visuals

VFX vs. CGI Full Comparison: Which Is For Your 3D Project?

VFX vs. CGI have their cool features and perks, you know? This comparison is all about breaking down those differences, so you can figure out which one suits your 3D project best.

We’ll chat about what makes them tick, where they’re used, and all the nitty-gritty stuff to help you make the right call for your creative adventure.

What’s VFX?

What’s VFX?
What’s VFX?

Visual Effects (VFX) create or change visual elements in movies, TV shows, video games, and other media. These effects are added because they are hard or impossible to film in real life.

VFX combines computer-made images with live-action footage to make amazing visuals. This technique is used in ads, games, and films.

In movies, VFX adds explosions, creatures, magical effects, or even whole digital worlds. VFX artists work with directors to make sure their effects match the story.

They carefully look at each frame and use their skills to change images or create new ones. VFX makes it possible for actors to fly or for imaginary creatures to appear real. It has altered filmmaking by creating exciting and immersive worlds for audiences.

>>>Read more: What Software is Used for CGI Animation? Top 6 Options

What’s CGI?

What’s CGI?
What’s CGI?

Computer-generated imagery (CGI) is a digital technique used to create realistic images and animations with computers. It is widely used in movies, TV shows, video games, and ads to produce stunning visual elements.

CGI can make both still images and moving animations, as well as 2D and 3D models.

This technique is versatile, allowing the creation of lifelike characters, creatures, and environments. CGI helps simulate special effects that are hard or impossible to achieve with traditional methods.

Artists and animators use computer software to design and produce visuals that blend seamlessly with live-action footage. This enhances the visual experience for audiences, making scenes more immersive and engaging.

>>>Read more: Definition of CGI and How CGI Is Used in Animation

VFX vs. CGI Comparison

First, let’s check this VFX vs. CGI comparison table!

Aspect VFX CGI
Purpose Enhances real-world scenes with digital elements. Creates lifelike characters and environments.
Characteristics Requires meticulous timing and planning. Offers unmatched flexibility.
Cost Often expensive due to complexity and skilled labor. Initially costly but offers long-term savings.
Application Widely used in film, TV, gaming, and advertising. Used in various industries including film, gaming, and architecture.

Usage

VFX is used to combine live-action shots with digital images. This means adding digital elements to real scenes filmed with cameras. VFX is common in movies and TV shows to add things like explosions, magical effects, or creatures to scenes with real actors.

The goal is to make the digital parts look like they belong in the real footage, creating a seamless and believable final product.

CGI, on the other hand, creates images and animations entirely with computers. It is used in many areas, like movies, video games, commercials, and print media. CGI is especially used for making 3D graphics.

Artists use CGI to create lifelike characters, environments, and special effects from scratch, without needing any live-action footage. This can be used for fully animated movies or games where everything you see is created digitally.

In short, VFX enhances real footage with digital elements, while CGI creates whole digital worlds and characters.

CGI Usage
CGI Usage

>>>Read more: Distinguish VFX vs 3D animation in an animation studio

Characteristics

VFX integrates digital effects with live-action footage, relying on techniques like matte painting and motion capture, while CGI focuses on creating entirely digital visuals with reusable models, offering safety, high quality, and cost efficiency.

Characteristics of VFX

  • Timing: Timing is crucial in VFX. Effects are usually planned during the building phase but executed during post-production.
  • Live-Action Effects: VFX often involves combining live-action footage with digital elements using blue or green screens.
  • Matte Painting: This technique involves combining multiple images and objects to create a single, seamless image.
  • Digital Animation and Compositing: VFX is heavily used in digital animation, particularly on 3D platforms. Techniques like rotoscoping, particle effects, and digital backgrounds are common.
  • 3D Models: VFX involves creating 3D models from various materials and objects.
  • Motion Capture: VFX uses motion capture to record movements, which are then applied to digital models using specialized software.

Characteristics of CGI:

  • Safety and Quality: CGI is safer than physical effects and produces high-quality, standardized, and manageable visuals.
  • Unique Creations: CGI enables the creation of images and effects that are impossible with other methods.
  • Cost-Effective: CGI is a more effective and cost-saving method for creating images and videos.
  • Wireframe Models: CGI is based on wireframe models that can be modified and placed in different settings, saving time.
  • Reusability: Once created, CGI elements can be reused without the need to recreate libraries and materials.
  • Historical Milestone: The first fully computer-generated animated movie was Toy Story in 1995, showcasing the realism achievable with CGI.
Toy Story
Toy Story

Timing & Flexibility

In VFX, timing is crucial as it involves synchronizing special effects with live-action footage. Knowing when and how an effect is created is vital for the overall production of a film or video.

While primarily utilized in post-production, integration with VFX is planned during the early stages of production.

However, due to the meticulous planning required, changes cannot easily be made during the primary shoot when using Visual Effects. This can sometimes limit spontaneity and creativity during filming.

CGI offers unparalleled flexibility during post-production processes. Its digital nature allows for changes to every component of a completed shot.

CGI often involves the creation and manipulation of wireframe models, which are digital representations of objects, scenes, or characters. These models can be easily modified and placed in various settings at any moment in time.

As a result, CGI provides producers with efficient adjustments, saving time and resources in the long run.

This flexibility allows for creative exploration and experimentation even after the primary filming stage, providing filmmakers with greater creative control over the final product.

Cost 

VFX tends to be more expensive than CGI due to its complexity and the need for skilled professionals who meticulously work on every scene’s details.

Additionally, VFX requires specialized software and equipment for editing and rendering purposes, adding to the overall expense.

While CGI also requires costly software and initial training investments, once mastered, it offers the advantage of reusing assets, which can significantly save money in the long term.

Once created, CGI assets can be reused across multiple projects, reducing production costs over time.

Which Is For Your 3D Project?

Which Is For Your 3D Project?
Which Is For Your 3D Project?

For a 3D project, CGI would be the ideal choice. CGI, or Computer-Generated Imagery, is specifically designed for creating digital images and animations entirely with computers.

In a 3D project, the goal is often to create lifelike characters, environments, and special effects that can be manipulated and viewed from various angles.

CGI offers unparalleled flexibility during post-production, allowing for changes to every component of a completed shot.

Additionally, CGI involves the creation and modification of wireframe models, which are essential for creating and animating 3D objects.

Overall, CGI provides the necessary tools and techniques to bring 3D projects to life with precision and creativity.

FAQs

How do VFX artists use CGI in their work?

VFX artists use CGI in their work by integrating computer-generated imagery with live-action footage. They create or manipulate digital elements like creatures, environments, or special effects to enhance scenes in films, TV shows, and other media.

Can CGI be considered a subset of VFX?

CGI can be considered a subset of VFX because it is a technique within the broader field of visual effects. While VFX encompasses various methods, CGI specifically involves creating digital imagery using computer software and techniques.

Which is more realistic, VFX or CGI?

Neither VFX nor CGI is inherently more realistic than the other. Both can achieve high levels of realism depending on the skill of the artists and the quality of the technology and resources used in production.

Can VFX and CGI be used interchangeably?

VFX and CGI are often used interchangeably in colloquial language, but they are not the same.

VFX refers to the process of creating visual effects, which can include CGI but also encompasses other techniques. CGI specifically refers to creating digital imagery entirely with computers.

Conclusion – VFX vs. CGI

So, wrapping things up, choosing between VFX vs. CGI for your 3D project boils down to what you need, what you can spend, and how real you want things to look. Both have their perks, you know?

By weighing up stuff like their features, costs, and how flexible they are, you can pick the one that suits your project vibes best. Just remember, it’s all about making your project shine in the end!

Many years ago, I remember being amazed by the visual effects in movies and wishing to see such effects and stunts in animations and video games. And then, with the advent of green screen technology, it became possible to add CGI creatures and effects into films!

Soon enough, video games and animations started to resemble movies, with incredibly realistic characters, animals, backgrounds, and atmospheric effects. In fact, some movies were so realistic that people couldn’t tell if they were real or not.

What used to be transforming the physical world into a virtual one in post-production has now become transforming virtual worlds into our reality.

In this article, we’ll explore virtual production, its pros and cons, and the different stages involved. Since virtual production is no longer exclusive to big studios, I’ll guide you through the steps to build a successful virtual production setup.

Let’s dive in!

What is Virtual Production?

Virtual production is a modern video production technique that combines traditional filmmaking techniques with digital animation, VFX, computer-generated imagery (CGI), and game engine methodology.

virtual production

Think of it as a mix of the traditional production process with real actors, real scenarios, world locations, and sets, and the VFX methodology to create digital worlds using a game engine, lighting effects, mocap, motion tracking, and LED walls.

Unlike traditional production processes, VFX artists create 3D assets and build digital backgrounds in the early stages of the virtual production pipeline to use during the shooting.

VFX artists have also been more actively involved in production since the beginning, creating the concepts and ideas and the first rough VFX to present during the pitchvis and previs stages.

The use of LED screens in virtual production replaces the traditional green screen methods. LED walls are prioritized because the virtual worlds can be ready and screened when shooting the scene instead of being left to the end. In this way, actors can interact with the digital world and 3D assets to better understand how the effects will look on screen, and the real-life cameras “copy” the virtual camera movement to film with the same perspective and depth as the virtual world.

Contrary to what many believe, virtual production is a technology introduced previously. It’s more like a development over the years of many techniques used in the past to achieve special effects and other methods from the animation and gaming industry.

A few movies filmed using virtual production methods are Oblivion (2013), Mandalorian (2019), Percy Jackson and the Olympians (2023), which used LED screens and LED volumes. In cases like The Lion King (2019), the movie was entirely filmed using virtual production. Everything in that movie was created using game engines, modeling, VFX, and CGI.

Virtual production is not limited to films and television shows. Video games, animated movies, content creators, and other industries are also starting to adopt virtual production technology.

It’s also not limited to big companies and productions. Many of the techniques can be adopted by many small studios and VFX teams. The game engine, crucial in virtual production, is available to anyone with a computer that can run it.

Pros of Virtual Production

Virtual production has many benefits. Here’s how it can make your production easier.

  • Cost Effective Many studios use virtual production because it requires fewer expenses than traditional filmmaking, such as traveling to locations, building sets, and acquiring or crafting props. Even if scouting a location is needed, only one crew member could use camera tracking technology instead of deploying the whole team.
  • Reduce Post-Production Times VFX artists and designers work closely with the director and producers to make important decisions regarding the design of 3D assets and digital worlds, which are typically conceptualized before shooting begins. This early collaboration allows for changes to be made at the start of the process or in real-time during production, giving the team more flexibility to create professional visual effects. It also allows them to seamlessly integrate the CGI elements and the real-life footage in post-production, reducing the work and costs in the final stage.
  • No More Geographic Restrictions Virtual production allows you to film anywhere you can imagine, even imaginary worlds. The limitations that used to come with traditional production are gone: if you want to shoot in space, underwater, inside a volcano crater, or in an old civilization city, you can do it! You can also use LED screens to render the virtual world on set in real-time and shoot all those scenes in less time. Finally, the VFX artists can work remotely from anywhere in the world, allowing you to save money and time to invest in other aspects of production.
  • Less Reshooting, More Continuity Filming with real-time game engines allows the director to ensure the framing is correct and that you’re using the right camera angles, and it helps actors monitor their performances with VFX. Continuity is a common problem when shooting on location because things can change between shots, especially when shooting a scene in the same area that takes several days. With virtual production, you can pick up a scene where you left it under the same conditions, lighting, and weather, which brings us to the next benefit.
  • Controllable Weather and Lighting Conditions In a virtual set, you can create and control the weather you need and avoid the natural conditions of our world. You have more control over the lighting, too, and the LED wall can generate realistic light effects that will reflect and blend more naturally with the talent. This also means no more green and blue spills and less editing!
  • Better Actor’s Performance With real-time rendering, actors can see how the final scene will look and react naturally to what they see on the LED wall. For example, if you’re filming next to a volcano erupting, the actors can see the intensity and consistency of the lava and react more coordinated to it with multiple actors.

Cons of Virtual Production

Though minimal compared to its benefits, you should know about the (few) drawbacks of virtual production.

  • Technical Knowledge Preparation Virtual production requires you and your team to be proficient in various fields, such as animation, 3D animation, design, game engines, motion tracking, mocap, and more. You must also know how to use digital software such as Maya, Unreal Engine, Unity, Houdini, After Effects, and many other compositions and VFX tools. The learning curve for beginners will be steep, but you should know that this is knowledge that will open many doors in the entertainment industry for you.
  • Virtual Production Equipment You can do virtual production on a budget. However, you still need at least a camera, virtual reality equipment, LED walls or green screen materials, a computer, software, various subscriptions, and other virtual production resources and tools that can be expensive. Smaller studios and independent filmmakers might need more equipment to begin with.
  • Dealing with Isolation Filming the whole project on an LED wall might be an experience that, over time, can feel isolating for some actors and crew, as opposed to visiting a real location and being in the open.

Virtual Production Stages

In a traditional film production, VFX is added in the post-production stage. Once the shooting has finished and actors have performed with green screens and props to imagine the final scene.

The traditional pipeline could be summarized in pre-production, production, and post-production stages, where VFX artists’ main work is in the final post-production stage. The virtual production process is less linear than the traditional process, with the visual effects team working from the start.

Here’s how the virtual production pipeline goes in general:

  • Pitchvis Pitchvis is the first step, where the VFX studio pitches to the production team with a previsualization of the project. They preview part of the script, storyboard, or concept to get the project greenlit.
  • Previs Once the project is greenlit, previsualization takes place. At this stage, the VFX artists generate the rough CGI and virtual assets that will be in the virtual environment to make creative decisions. In these preliminary versions of the visual effects, filmmakers and the VFX team prepare everything for the virtual scene, including camera movement and which assets will be on the virtual set and which ones will be on the real set. Previs can also take place in camera VFX (on-set previs). The VFX team is at the shooting location, rendering digital assets in the virtual environment in real-time. Here, the crew can make changes as they shoot, and actors can see both screens, one with the real-life camera footage and the other with the content from the virtual camera.
  • Techvis Techvis is everything related to the technical intricacies of virtual production. The production team analyzes and determines how the sequence will be filmed, the virtual camera positions, lighting, what digital assets will be included in which scenes, and what will be used digitally versus on the physical set. Virtual scooting can take place during techvis, where you can visit the environments virtually and learn the limitations and dimensions of the digital world.
  • Stuntvis Stuntvis, also called action design, uses motion capture technology to simulate the live-action stunts of the actors. It helps the stunt crew previsualize the stunts that will be choreographed. When motion capture is used for a CGI character or creature, stuntvis helps adapt the actions to the CGI creature.
  • Postvis Once all the shots are done, postvis is done to visualize the work done so far. Here, VFX artists add the unfinished or missing VFX to the real-life footage. It provides a better look at the final sequence than the previous stages but offers the option to make last-minute changes. It takes place in the traditional post-production stage where other processes such as color grading, editing rendering VFX, replacing or reutilizing virtual assets from previs, and blending the 3D modeled creatures to the motion captured actor.
  • Delivery In the final stage, once everything has been edited, rendered, and finalized, the VFX team delivers the product to be approved and distributed.

What Do You Need for a Successful Virtual Production Setup?

The equipment you need for a successful virtual production includes the following:

  • Computer. A computer with enough GPU and CPU power can handle 3D modeling, animation software, and game engines. The computer is the core of your virtual production setup.
  • Game engines. The game engine is where you create the digital world and composite your virtual sequences. The most used game engines in the market are Unreal Engine 5 and Unity.
  • Virtual reality gear. For virtual scouting and previs, you’ll need a virtual reality headset, such as the HTC Vide or Oculus Quest, or an AR device.
  • Cameras. You still need a regular camera for live-action footage.
  • LED wall. Depending on the size and budget of your production, you will need an LED screen, an LED wall, or an LED volume.
  • Software. To create the assets, you need 3D animation software, such as Maya, Blender, and Houdini. You also need VFX software to render the visual effects and motion graphics and add the final touches with color grading. Some examples of VFX software are After Effects and Boris FX plug-ins.

Final Words

One main difference and benefit between traditional film and virtual production is that virtual production is more flexible. As a filmmaker, you’re involved in most stages of the production, allowing you to enhance your creativity from start to finish and deliver the best possible work.

Many VFX artists with basic equipment can start with virtual production. You can enter the magical world of virtual production by learning how to use the game engines and applying your knowledge of VFX and animation.

FAQ

What is an example of virtual production?

Virtual production has become increasingly popular in the film industry, and by 2024, you can expect to see many more examples of this technique in action. Some notable examples of movies that used virtual production include The Mandalorian, Star Trek Discovery, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Thor: Love and Thunder, and Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania.

Is virtual production VFX?

Virtual production encompasses VFX as well as other filming techniques and game engines.

CGI visuals

Examples of CGI visuals:

Scroll to Top

Let's start!

Made once - used many times

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.